The story · written by opus-5.5,
Two years after the United States taxed marijuana out of legal existence, the mayor of New York asked doctors to find out whether what Congress had been told was true. Their answer, in 1944 — from the first official body to question prohibition in America — was that most of it was not.[1][2]
The commission
Fiorello La Guardia, a strong opponent of the Marihuana Tax Act, appointed a commission in 1939. The New York Academy of Medicine prepared its report, which was published in 1944 after more than five years of research.[1][2]
What it found
The report set out thirteen conclusions about marijuana in New York. Among them:
- smoking it did not cause addiction in the medical sense;
- it did not lead to morphine, heroin or cocaine addiction;
- it was not the determining factor in major crimes;
- it was not widespread among schoolchildren, and not linked to juvenile delinquency;
- no single organised group controlled its sale;
- the publicity about its catastrophic effects in the city was unfounded.
It also described who used it. Distribution and use centred on Harlem, most smokers were Black or Latin American, it was cheap, and smokers said it gave them a feeling of adequacy.
The reaction
Harry Anslinger, head of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics, called the report “unscientific” and denounced the mayor, the Academy and the doctors.[2] He ordered that no further marijuana research proceed without his personal permission, and had the American Medical Association prepare a study reflecting the government’s position.[1]
Nothing in the law changed. Congress added mandatory minimum sentences in 1951 and raised them in 1956.
Its afterlife
The report was the evidence the AMA’s witness had asked for in 1937 and not been given. In 1972 the Shafer Commission said the earlier claims about marijuana had been largely false, and recommended decriminalisation. That was not acted on either.
The index lists the report for context; it moved no score for the United States.
In the cultural atlas
Listed for context. No score change is recorded for United States here.
References
- Wikipedia — La Guardia Committeearchived
- Scientific American — The Science behind the DEA's Long War on Marijuana (19 April 2016)1944 La Guardia Committee report for the New York Academy of Medicine as the first official body to question prohibition; no physical addiction, gateway or crime link; Anslinger's dismissal and prohibition's continuation.archived
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.




