The story · written by opus-5.5,
On 2 November 1951 Congress passed the Boggs Act, named for its sponsor, the Louisiana Democrat Hale Boggs.[1] For the first time federal law set one scale of penalties for marijuana and for heroin, and for repeat offenders it took sentencing out of the judge’s hands.[2][1]
A heroin scare
The law was aimed at opiates, not marijuana. Between 1948 and 1951 arrests and admissions of young addicts rose sharply. Boggs told the House that in the first half of 1950, 766 patients under 21 had been admitted to the federal hospital at Lexington, against three in the same period of 1946. Congress blamed lenient judges, and the Federal Bureau of Narcotics, in a survey of its own, found that the average federal narcotics sentence had barely changed since 1935.[1]
Marijuana was swept in because it was already part of the federal drug laws. At the hearings Harris Isbell, research director at Lexington, testified that marijuana smokers were usually mildly intoxicated, harmed no one and developed no dependence. Harry Anslinger answered that over half of the young heroin addicts had started on marijuana. He had rejected this stepping-stone argument in 1937; now it became the official case for punishing marijuana like heroin.[1]
The penalties
| Conviction | Prison | Probation or parole |
|---|---|---|
| First | 2–5 years | Possible |
| Second | 5–10 years | Not available |
| Third and later | 10–20 years | Not available |
Every offence also carried a fine of up to $2,000.[2][1] Boggs argued that the law could not draw a line between possession and peddling without opening it to abuse.[1]
Little Boggs acts
The bureau urged the states to follow. By 1953 seventeen states and the territory of Alaska had passed “little Boggs acts”, and eleven more raised penalties by 1956. Ohio set twenty to forty years for selling narcotics, and Louisiana five to ninety-nine years without parole for selling, possessing or administering a narcotic drug.[1]
Judges objected. On 27 May 1954 the district and circuit judges of the Fifth Circuit unanimously asked Congress to remove the mandatory minimums. Boggs called it a shortsighted recommendation.[1] Two years later Congress went the other way with the Narcotic Control Act, which raised the fine to $20,000 and barred probation and parole for everyone except first-time possessors.[3][1]
Undone in 1970
The Controlled Substances Act of 1970 placed cannabis in Schedule I, removed the mandatory minimums and made simple possession a misdemeanour. Mandatory federal sentences returned in 1986, this time tied to quantity.[3]
Why the index moved
The Boggs Act lowered the United States total from 11 to 9, with enforcement falling from 2 to 1: two to five years for a first possession offence, and prison without probation for any repeat, mean that users go to prison as a matter of course. The 1956 act took the total to 7, the lowest it has been.
Score by segment 0 to 10
- Possession · 25%1 → 1
- Personal cultivation · 25%1 → 1
- Punishment & enforcement · 20%2 → 1−1
- Sharing & gifting · 10%1 → 1
- Consumption · 10%1 → 1
- Legal access · 10%0 → 0
The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. United States's scores have changed again since.
References
- The Marijuana Conviction: A History of Marijuana Prohibition in the United StatesRichard J. Bonnie, Charles H. Whitebread II · The Lindesmith Center · 1999 · chapter 11, pp. 204–215 · ISBN 1891385062
- Wikipedia — Boggs Act of 1951archived
- Wikipedia — Legal history of cannabis in the United Statesarchived
- Wikipedia — Boggs Actarchived
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.



