Cannabis Freedom Index
← History

Easing 🇺🇸 United States

The United States passes the Controlled Substances Act

The Act replaced the tax law struck down the year before. It put marijuana in Schedule I, the category for drugs with no accepted medical use, where it largely remains. It also repealed the mandatory minimum sentences of the 1950s and made simple possession a misdemeanour.[4][1][5]

Index score

711

+4 points

The story · written by opus-5.5,

In 1970 the United States put marijuana in the same legal category as heroin. The official who proposed it meant it as a placeholder, to last until a commission had studied the question. The commission reported in 1972. Most of the placeholder is still there.

A law needed in a hurry

In 1969 the Supreme Court struck down the Marihuana Tax Act, the basis of federal cannabis law since 1937. President Nixon’s administration was already preparing a comprehensive drug measure.

It moved quickly and with almost no opposition. The bill passed the House on 24 September 1970 by 341 votes to 6 and the Senate on 7 October by 54 to 0. Nixon signed it on 27 October.

Five schedules

The Act sorts drugs into five schedules by two tests: potential for abuse, and accepted medical use. Schedule I is for drugs with a high potential for abuse, “no currently accepted medical use” and no accepted safety under medical supervision.

Marijuana went there, with heroin. The recommendation came from Roger Egeberg, the assistant secretary of health, who advised placing it in Schedule I temporarily, until the commission created by the same Act had reported.

In one respect the law was milder than what it replaced. It abolished the mandatory minimum sentences of the 1950s and made simple possession a misdemeanour.

The commission

Nixon appointed the thirteen members, with a former governor of Pennsylvania, Raymond Shafer, in the chair. Their report, “Marihuana: A Signal of Misunderstanding”, was presented on 22 March 1972.

It found that users were not the dangerous figures of public belief but “more timid, drowsy and passive”, and that cannabis did not threaten society. It recommended ending criminal penalties for possession. Shafer told Congress:

The criminal law is too harsh a tool to apply to personal possession even in the effort to discourage use.

Nixon had answered in advance. “Even if the commission does recommend that it be legalized, I will not follow that recommendation.” Neither he nor Congress acted.

What followed

The states did. Oregon decriminalised possession in 1973 and ten more followed by 1978. Federal law went the other way: mandatory minimums returned in 1986.

Schedule I proved hard to leave. In 1988 the drug agency’s own judge said cannabis should be moved, and was overruled. Only in 2026 did state-licensed medical cannabis move to Schedule III.

In the index the Act is recorded as a slight easing for the United States: enforcement rose from 0 to 2 with the end of mandatory prison, while every other score stayed where the 1950s had left it.[1][2][3]

Score by segment 0 to 10

  1. Possession · 25%1 1
  2. Personal cultivation · 25%1 1
  3. Punishment & enforcement · 20%0 2+2
  4. Sharing & gifting · 10%1 1
  5. Consumption · 10%1 1
  6. Legal access · 10%0 0

The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. United States's scores have changed again since.

References

  1. Wikipedia — Controlled Substances Actarchived
  2. Wikipedia — National Commission on Marihuana and Drug Abusearchived
  3. TNI / GDPO — The Rise and Decline of Cannabis Prohibition (2014)archived
  4. Wikipedia — Legal history of cannabis in the United Statesarchived
  5. PRIDE International and Drug War Diplomacy: The Parent Movement’s Global Battle against Marijuana in the United States, ca. 1970–1985Emily Dufton · In Cannabis: Global Histories, edited by Lucas Richert, James H. Mills · MIT Press · 2021 · pp. 297 · ISBN 9780262366137

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.