Cannabis Freedom Index
← History

Debate 🇺🇸 United States

A DEA judge says cannabis should be rescheduled

Administrative law judge Francis Young ruled that cannabis should be moved to Schedule II, calling it one of the safest therapeutically active substances known. The DEA administrator rejected the recommendation the following year.[3][1]

The story · written by opus-5.5,

In 1988 the United States drug agency’s own judge examined whether marijuana belonged among the most dangerous drugs. He ruled that it did not.[1] His agency overruled him.[1]

Sixteen years to a hearing

Marijuana was placed in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act in 1970, the category for drugs with no accepted medical use. In 1972 the reform group NORML petitioned to have it moved to Schedule II, which would have allowed doctors to prescribe it.[1]

The agency refused even to consider the petition. It took three court orders, in 1974, 1977 and 1980, to make the government process it and carry out the scientific and medical evaluation the law requires.[2] Hearings finally opened in the summer of 1986 and lasted about two years.[2][1]

The ruling

On 6 September 1988 the Drug Enforcement Administration’s chief administrative law judge, Francis L. Young, gave his decision. Marijuana, he wrote, was

one of the safest therapeutically active substances known to man.[1]

It did not meet the criteria for Schedule I, and the Act required that it be moved to Schedule II, which would recognise its medicinal value and let doctors prescribe it.[1]

The answer

The ruling was a recommendation to the agency’s administrator, John Lawn, who rejected it. In 1994 an appeals court confirmed that the administrator had the power to overrule his judge, and the petition, twenty-two years old, was dead.

What followed

Later petitions, filed in 1995, 2002, 2009 and 2011, were all denied, the last of them in 2016. Change came by another route. Federal health officials recommended Schedule III in 2023, and in 2026 state-licensed medical cannabis was moved there.

The index lists Judge Young’s ruling for context. It changed no law, but it is the clearest case of the evidence being heard, in the forum the law provided, and set aside.

Listed for context. No score change is recorded for United States here.

References

  1. Congressional Research Service — Medical Marijuana: Review and Analysis of Federal and State Policies (RL33211)1972 BNDD petition and rejection; 1988 Young ruling with the safest-substance finding and Schedule I to II order; DEA Administrator rejection; later petitions denied.archived
  2. Wikipedia — Removal of cannabis from Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Actarchived
  3. Wikipedia — Legal history of cannabis in the United Statesarchived

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.