Cannabis Freedom Index
← History
Exhibition 001 · Propaganda · this event is part of itReefer MadnessThe invention of a monsterEnter the exhibition

Debate 🇺🇸 United States

The Shafer Commission recommends decriminalisation

The national commission created by the Controlled Substances Act recommended removing criminal penalties for possessing and casually distributing small amounts.[4][5]

The story · written by opus-5.5,

President Nixon appointed a commission to study marijuana and announced in advance that he would ignore it if it recommended legalisation. It recommended ending the crime of possession. He ignored it.[1]

Why it existed

When Congress wrote the Controlled Substances Act in 1970, it put marijuana in Schedule I, with heroin.[1] A senior health official had advised that this be temporary, pending a study, and the Act created a commission to carry it out.[1]

Nixon appointed the members and chose a former governor of Pennsylvania, Raymond Shafer, to chair them. They included doctors, a television producer and four members of Congress.[1]

The report

“Marihuana: A Signal of Misunderstanding” was presented to Congress and the public on 22 March 1972.[1]

It found that the public’s picture of the user was wrong. Smokers were not dangerous; they were, if anything, “more timid, drowsy and passive”.[1] Cannabis did not pose a widespread danger to society, and the commission compared it to alcohol.[1]

Its recommendation followed. Possession for personal use should no longer be an offence, and use should be discouraged by means other than the criminal law.[1] Shafer told Congress:

The criminal law is too harsh a tool to apply to personal possession even in the effort to discourage use.[2]

The answer

Nixon had said: “Even if the commission does recommend that it be legalized, I will not follow that recommendation.” Neither he nor Congress acted, and in 1974 a Senate subcommittee came out against decriminalisation.[3]

The effect it did have

The states listened. Oregon made possession of an ounce a civil matter in 1973, and a dozen states had done something similar by 1978, covering more than a third of the population.[3]

That in turn produced a reaction. A parents’ movement formed in 1976 and, by its historian’s account, had most of those laws overturned by 1980.[3]

Marijuana stayed in Schedule I. The report has been cited ever since by those arguing that it should not be, alongside the La Guardia report before it and Judge Young’s ruling after.

The index lists the report for context; it moved no score for the United States.

Listed for context. No score change is recorded for United States here.

References

  1. Wikipedia — National Commission on Marihuana and Drug Abusearchived
  2. TNI / GDPO — The Rise and Decline of Cannabis Prohibition (2014)archived
  3. PRIDE International and Drug War Diplomacy: The Parent Movement’s Global Battle against Marijuana in the United States, ca. 1970–1985Emily Dufton · In Cannabis: Global Histories, edited by Lucas Richert, James H. Mills · MIT Press · 2021 · pp. 297 · ISBN 9780262366137
  4. Wikipedia — Legal history of cannabis in the United Statesarchived
  5. PRIDE International and Drug War Diplomacy: The Parent Movement’s Global Battle against Marijuana in the United States, ca. 1970–1985Emily Dufton · In Cannabis: Global Histories, edited by Lucas Richert, James H. Mills · MIT Press · 2021 · pp. 297–319 · ISBN 9780262366137

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.