Cannabis Freedom Index
← History
Exhibition 001 · Propaganda · this event is part of itReefer MadnessThe invention of a monsterEnter the exhibition

Other law 🇺🇸 United States

The US Supreme Court strikes down the Marihuana Tax Act

In Leary v. United States the court ruled that the 1937 tax law, the basis of federal prohibition, forced people to incriminate themselves. State laws still banned cannabis, and Congress replaced the tax act with the Controlled Substances Act the following year.[2][1]

The story · written by opus-5.5,

The law that began federal cannabis prohibition in the United States was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1969.[1] The man who brought the case was the country’s best-known advocate of psychedelic drugs.[2]

The arrest

On 22 December 1965 Timothy Leary was driving back into the United States with his family across the international bridge at Laredo, Texas. At the inspection point officers searched the car. They found marijuana seeds and small amounts on the floor and in the glove compartment, and a silver snuff box with some marijuana and three partly smoked cigarettes on his daughter.[2][1]

He was charged under the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937.[1]

The trap in the law

The Act did not forbid marijuana. It taxed it. Anyone acquiring cannabis was supposed to register, obtain an order form and pay a tax, and it was failing to do so that was the federal offence.[1]

Leary’s argument was that the scheme could not be obeyed without confessing. To comply, he would have had to identify himself to the government as someone acquiring marijuana without being registered, and so hand over evidence of a crime.[1]

The ruling

The case was argued in December 1968 and decided on 19 May 1969. Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote the opinion. Compliance, the court held, created a “real and appreciable” hazard of self-incrimination, contrary to the Fifth Amendment. Leary’s conviction was reversed.[1]

The fiction that had made the Act possible in 1937, that it was a revenue measure and not a ban, was the thing that undid it.[2][1]

What replaced it

The ruling left federal law with a hole in it, though every state still had its own prohibition. Congress filled the hole within eighteen months. The Controlled Substances Act of October 1970 dropped the pretence of taxation, banned the drug directly and placed it in Schedule I.

So the decision that freed Leary produced a stronger law than the one it removed. It did bring one change for the better: the new Act abolished the mandatory minimum sentences of the 1950s.[2]

The index lists the ruling for context. Between May 1969 and October 1970 a person’s position under state law did not change, so it moved no score for the United States.

Listed for context. No score change is recorded for United States here.

References

  1. U.S. Supreme Court — Leary v. United States, 395 U.S. 6 (1969)Laredo crossing of 22 December 1965; argued December 1968, decided 19 May 1969, Harlan opinion; Fifth Amendment self-incrimination holding and reversal.archived
  2. Wikipedia — Leary v. United Statesarchived

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.