Cannabis Freedom Index
← History
Exhibition 001 · Propaganda · this event is part of itReefer MadnessThe invention of a monsterEnter the exhibition

Debate 🇮🇳 India

The Indian Hemp Drugs Commission reports

After hearing nearly 1,200 witnesses across British India, the commission concluded that moderate use of hemp drugs does practically no harm and that banning them would be unjustified.[1][4][3] It recommended taxing and licensing them, which remained the system in India until 1985.[5]

The story · written by opus-5.5,

One of the most exhaustive official studies of cannabis ever made was finished in 1894.[1][2] It advised against prohibition, and thirty years later the men who wrote the first cannabis treaty did not mention it.

A question in London

The inquiry did not begin in India. Temperance campaigners in the British House of Commons claimed that India’s lunatic asylums were filled with ganja smokers, and on 2 March 1893 the House took up the effects of hemp drugs in Bengal.[1][2] The Government of India appointed a commission of seven, and the inquiry was widened to the whole country.[1]

The president was W. Mackworth Young. Three of the seven members were Indian: Raja Soshi Sikhareshwar Roy, Kanwar Harnam Singh and Lala Nihal Chand.[1] They began work on 3 July 1893, heard almost 1,200 witnesses, among them doctors, clergy and smugglers, and visited asylums across India.[1] The report ran to more than 3,200 pages.[3]

What it found

The commission separated moderate use, which it called “the rule”, from excessive use, which was “comparatively exceptional”.[1]

Moderate useExcessive use
Body“No appreciable physical injury of any kind”Causes injury
Mind“No mental injury”Intensifies mental instability
Morals“No moral injury whatever”Intensifies weakness or depravity

On the claim that had started the inquiry, the members examined how asylum statistics were compiled and concluded that the effect of hemp drugs on insanity had “hitherto been greatly exaggerated”.[2] Most of the doctors involved thought cannabis brought out an illness already present, and that alcohol mattered at least as much.

Total prohibition, the report said, was “neither necessary nor expedient”.[2] It gave four reasons: the drugs’ known effects, how widespread the habit was, “the social and religious feeling on the subject”, and the risk of driving users to something worse.

Its policy was “control and restriction”: tax the drugs adequately, allow cultivation only under licence, limit the number of shops and limit how much a person could hold.[2] The 1896 excise act applied that approach in the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, the Punjab, the Central Provinces, Burma, Coorg, and Ajmere and Merwara. Other provinces kept their own excise. Licensed sale in the states continued until the 1985 ban.

What became of it

At Geneva in 1925 the Egyptian delegate told the conference that hashish caused 30 to 60 per cent of insanity in his country.[2] Britain and India opposed a ban, but neither delegation cited the commission’s report. A newspaper did: in 1926 the New York Times quoted it against the Egyptian claims.[2]

Later inquiries reached much the same conclusions, from New York’s La Guardia report to the commissions of the 1970s in Canada and the Netherlands.

The index lists the report for context; it moved no score in India.

Listed for context. No score change is recorded for India here.

References

  1. Wikipedia — Indian Hemp Drugs Commissionarchived
  2. TNI / GDPO — The Rise and Decline of Cannabis Prohibition (2014)archived
  3. Cannabis Britannica: Empire, Trade, and Prohibition, 1800–1928James H. Mills · Oxford University Press · 2003 · pp. 92–123 · ISBN 0-19-924938-5
  4. Ganja Madness: Cannabis, Insanity, and Indentured Labor in British Guiana and Trinidad, 1881–1912Jamie Banks · In Cannabis: Global Histories, edited by Lucas Richert, James H. Mills · MIT Press · 2021 · pp. 71 · ISBN 9780262366137
  5. Ganja and the Government of India: Cannabis, Excise, and Colonial Administration in the Late Nineteenth CenturyPeter Hynd · In Cannabis: Global Histories, edited by Lucas Richert, James H. Mills · MIT Press · 2021 · pp. 44, 48 · ISBN 9780262366137

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.