The story · written by muse-spark,
In 1968 Argentina did something no military government would be expected to do: it stopped punishing drug possession for personal use. Law 17,567 folded the word estupefacientes into the law, listed the trafficking offences with one to six years in prison — and made unlawful possession a crime only when it exceeded what personal use required.[1]
Six years of breathing room
The exemption sat on top of forty years of blanket prohibition. Argentina’s first narcotics law dated from 1924, and since 1926 even simple possession without a justification had been punishable.[1] The 1968 reform kept the trafficker’s penalty but drew, for the first time, a line between the dealer and the user. Argentina’s first narcotics law passed in 1924. Possession became a crime in 1926.
Repealed, then reversed
The breathing room lasted six years. In 1973 Law 20,509 repealed the 1968 code reform and the 1926 rules returned; a year later Law 20,771 — framed as national security — set one to six years for possession even for personal use.[1] The exemption was repealed in 1973. Personal possession became a crime again in 1974.
The long echo
It took the courts 35 years to get back to 1968. In 1986 the Supreme Court spared the rock guitarist Bazterrica and Capalbo, holding the 1974 law unconstitutional for private possession — then Menem’s 1989 law re-criminalised it and the court upheld that in 1990.[2] Only in 2009, in Arriola, did the court unanimously return to the principle the dictatorship’s reformers had written in 1968: private personal use is none of the criminal law’s business.[2] The court first protected personal use in 1986. The court protected private use in 2009. Argentina still waits for Congress to write that principle into statute.
Score by segment 0 to 10
- Possession · 25%1 → 3+2
- Personal cultivation · 25%1 → 1
- Punishment & enforcement · 20%2 → 4+2
- Sharing & gifting · 10%1 → 1
- Consumption · 10%1 → 3+2
- Legal access · 10%0 → 0
The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. Argentina's scores have changed again since.
References
- TNI — About drug law reform in Argentina (30 June 2015)Timeline 1924–1989; 1968 Law 17,567, personal-use exemption, one to six yearsarchived
- Wikipedia (Spanish) — Cannabis en ArgentinaBazterrica and Capalbo 1986; Montalbo; Arriola 2009; 2012 reform hearingsarchived
- Wikipedia — Cannabis in Argentinaarchived
- Pensamiento Penal — Evolución de la legislación argentina sobre estupefacientes
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.