Cannabis Freedom Index
← History

Easing 🇦🇷 Argentina

Argentina's Supreme Court first protects personal use

In Bazterrica, the Supreme Court held Article 6 of Law 20.771 unconstitutional insofar as it criminalised simple drug possession for personal use within the private sphere protected by Article 19 of the Constitution. The majority reversed the conviction and returned the case for a new decision. The ruling protected private conduct that did not harm others rather than authorising trafficking or every form of public drug use.[3]

Index score

1122

+11 points

The story · written by opus-5.5,

In 1986, three years after the end of military rule, Argentina’s Supreme Court held for the first time that the state may not punish an adult for holding drugs for personal use. The ruling is named after the defendant, a rock guitarist. It lasted four years as law, and it supplied the reasoning the court returned to in 2009.

Two cases

Gustavo Bazterrica was a well-known guitarist, a member of the rock band Los Abuelos de la Nada. Police found 3.6 grams of marijuana and 0.06 grams of cocaine. Alejandro Capalbo, whose case was decided with his, was stopped in a taxi with 54 grams of marijuana in his jacket pocket.

Both had been convicted under Law 20.771 of 1974, which punished possession “even if intended for personal use”.

The reasoning

The court declared that provision unconstitutional. Article 19 of the Constitution places private actions that harm no one beyond the reach of the authorities. The court held that the law intruded on conduct of that kind, so long as it involved no concrete danger or harm to the rights or property of others.

How it was undone

The legislature did not follow. The 1988 Vienna convention pushed towards stricter control, debate on a new drug law dragged on, and in 1989 the incoming government of Carlos Menem enacted Law 23.737, which again made possession for personal use a crime.

In 1990 the Supreme Court upheld the new law in the Montalvo case. It reasoned that there is no protected privacy once conduct is outwardly expressed, and that possession of any quantity can affect public order, morals or third parties.

YearCaseHolding
1986Bazterrica and Capalbopunishing personal possession is unconstitutional
1990Montalvothe 1989 law’s punishment of personal possession is valid
2009Arriolaunconstitutional again, on the Bazterrica reasoning

A Supreme Court ruling in Argentina binds only the parties, which is one reason the question could swing three times without the statute changing.

Why the index moved

The index moved Argentina from 11 to 22 with Bazterrica: possession and consumption from 1 to 3, and enforcement from 2 to 4. The same three segments fell back in 1989.[1][2]

Score by segment 0 to 10

  1. Possession · 25%1 3+2
  2. Personal cultivation · 25%1 1
  3. Punishment & enforcement · 20%2 4+2
  4. Sharing & gifting · 10%1 1
  5. Consumption · 10%1 3+2
  6. Legal access · 10%0 0

The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. Argentina's scores have changed again since.

References

  1. Wikipedia (Spanish) — Cannabis en Argentinaarchived
  2. Wikipedia (Spanish) — Fallo Arriolaarchived
  3. Supreme Court of Argentina — Bazterrica, original judgment reproduced by Pensamiento PenalDecision dated 29 August 1986, majority reasons 4–9 and 13 and operative order; distinguish preceding prosecutor's opinionarchived

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.