The story · written by deepseek-v4.1-flash,
On 4 July 2023, Malaysia stopped requiring judges to impose death on every person convicted of drug trafficking. The 2023 reform let a court choose imprisonment for life instead, and anyone spared death must receive at least 12 strokes of the cane.[1] For cannabis, the change reached the sentence and stopped there: possession, growing, consumption and the presumption that 200 g means trafficking all remained.[2]
A sentence with no room to argue
Malaysia made death the only sentence for trafficking in 1983, and the law presumed anyone holding 200 g of cannabis to be a trafficker.[2] Executions were paused in 2018, but courts continued to sentence people to death; by 2023, 1,337 people were under sentence of death.[3] An amendment that took effect in 2018 had allowed life imprisonment in limited circumstances, but the 2023 Act removed those limits.[1]
What the Act changed
The Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act deleted the subsections that had confined the alternative sentence and cut the whipping minimum for trafficking from 15 strokes to 12.[1] Section 39B now provides death or imprisonment for life, with at least 12 strokes where death is not imposed.[2] The change also applied to offences committed before 4 July 2023, so people already convicted could be sentenced under the new choice.[1] A companion law, in force on 12 September 2023, gave the Federal Court temporary power to review death sentences that had already exhausted ordinary appeals.[3]
Who came off death row
The Federal Court reviewed 936 cases under its temporary jurisdiction and finished on 29 October 2024. In total it commuted 900 death sentences, including 46 in ordinary review, and the Court of Appeal commuted another 116 in 2024.[3] By 22 January 2025, 140 people remained on death row, including 40 convicted of drug offences.[3] The reform did not end long prison terms: in January 2025 the High Court in Kuala Lumpur sentenced three men to life imprisonment and 18 strokes for trafficking 707.05 g of cannabis and cultivating plants, with the terms running from their 2021 arrest.[4]
The cannabis law stayed
Cannabis is still a dangerous drug with no lawful recreational supply. Possession of 20 g brings caning, 50 g can bring life, growing a single plant brings life and at least six strokes, and consumption carries up to two years or a RM5,000 fine.[2] The 2023 Act changed who decides the sentence for trafficking, not whether trafficking is an offence. In October 2026 a policy brief launched in Parliament by the Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network, Monash University Malaysia and Eleos Justice called for the death penalty to be abolished for drug offences; it noted that 97 people remained on death row in November 2025, 21% of them convicted of drug offences.[5] The debate has moved beyond the mandatory sentence. The cannabis provisions of Malaysia’s drug law have not moved with it.
Listed for context. No score change is recorded for Malaysia here.
References
- Malaysia — Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023 (Act 846)Section 54 (amendment of section 39B), section 55 (transitional); Royal Assent 9 June 2023, gazetted 16 June 2023archived
- Malaysia — Dangerous Drugs Act 1952 (Act 234), online text as at 26 November 2025Sections 6B(3), 37(da), 39A and 39B(2)archived
- Amnesty International Malaysia — Malaysia: two years since mandatory sentencing repeal, government urged to fully abolish the death penalty (4 July 2025)Federal Court review concluded 29 October 2024 after 936 cases; 900 commutations; 140 on death row at 22 January 2025, including 40 drug offendersarchived
- Malay Mail — KL High Court hands life sentences to trio convicted of drug trafficking and cultivating cannabis (7 January 2025)Sentence, charges and December 2021 arrestarchived
- Sinar Daily — Study urges end to death penalty for drug offences (28 October 2026)Policy brief launched 27 October 2026; 97 on death row in November 2025; 21% drug offencesarchived
- Malaysia Ministry of Health — Dangerous Drugs Act 1952, incorporating Act 846Section 39B(2), deleted (2A)–(2B), amendment and transitional notes, printed p.38archived
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.