The story · written by opus-5.5,
On 12 February 2014 Italy’s Constitutional Court struck down the drug law that had treated cannabis like heroin for eight years. It did not rule on whether the law was too harsh. It ruled that Parliament had passed it the wrong way.
A drug law inside an Olympic decree
At the end of 2005 the government issued an emergency decree, number 272, on security and funding for the coming Winter Olympics. One article of it dealt with drugs, and only to keep addicts who reoffended in treatment programmes. When Parliament converted the decree into law in February 2006, it added twenty-three further articles. Together they rewrote the country’s drug law, the 1990 consolidated text, and merged the separate schedules for “light” and “heavy” drugs into one. This was the Fini-Giovanardi law.
| Producing or selling cannabis | Prison | Fine |
|---|---|---|
| Before 2006 | 2 to 6 years | €5,164 to €77,468 |
| Under the 2006 law | 6 to 20 years | €26,000 to €260,000 |
The case
The question came from the Court of Cassation, whose third criminal section was hearing an appeal in a drug case. In June 2013 it asked the Constitutional Court whether the 2006 changes were valid. A law converting a decree, it argued, may only contain what belongs to the decree’s subject and purpose, under article 77 of the Constitution. These amendments had no such link.
The court agreed. A conversion law, it held, cannot be opened to any content at all; otherwise the fast procedure meant for emergencies could be used for other ends, bypassing the ordinary debate in Parliament. Adding unrelated articles was an abuse of the power to convert.
What came back
Because the 2006 provisions had never validly replaced the old ones, the court said, the earlier text of article 73 and its schedules applied again. That was the 1990 law as changed by the 1993 referendum: possession for personal use an administrative offence, and cannabis once more in a lighter class than heroin or cocaine. Il Post wrote that the struck-down law had contributed decisively to the overcrowding of Italian prisons.
The court left it to ordinary judges to make sure that no defendant was worse off as a result. At the end of May 2014 the Court of Cassation ruled that people imprisoned under the annulled provisions had the right to be resentenced. Grazia Zuffa, of the Italian group Forum Droghe, wrote that this could affect about 10,000 prisoners held for cannabis offences.
Afterwards
The ruling restored a distinction; it legalised nothing. Producing and selling cannabis remained crimes in Italy, and a later attempt to change that by referendum was blocked by the same court in 2022.[1][2][3]
Score by segment 0 to 10
- Possession · 25%2 → 3+1
- Personal cultivation · 25%1 → 1
- Punishment & enforcement · 20%3 → 4+1
- Sharing & gifting · 10%1 → 1
- Consumption · 10%2 → 2
- Legal access · 10%1 → 2+1
The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. Italy's scores have changed again since.
References
- Corte costituzionale — Sentenza 32/2014 (decided 12 February, filed 25 February 2014)archived
- Il Post — La Corte costituzionale ha bocciato la Fini-Giovanardi (12 February 2014)archived
- TNI / UNGASS on Drugs — Grazia Zuffa, Prisoners sentenced with unconstitutional norms have the right to be resentenced (5 June 2014)archived
- DPNSEE — Italy, the legal map on decriminalisation policies (PDF)archived
- Wikipedia (Italian) — Legge Fini-Giovanardiarchived
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.