The story · written by opus-5.5,
Beka Tsikarishvili was accused of buying and possessing 69 grams of dried marijuana. Under article 260(2) of Georgia’s Criminal Code that was a “large quantity”, and the penalty was imprisonment for seven years or more. On 5 May 2014 he lodged a complaint with the Constitutional Court. The First Chamber gave judgment on 24 October 2015.
The question
The complaint did not ask the court to legalise anything. It challenged the words that set the prison term, under article 17(2) of the Constitution, which prohibits torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading punishment. While the case was pending, Parliament cut the penalty for the same conduct to five to eight years. The court held that it could still rule, because the new wording repeated the substance of the old.
The reasoning
The court said that imprisonment is not in itself inhuman, but a clearly disproportionate sentence can be. It then looked at whom the act endangers.
- Using marijuana “might have negative effect on human health”, but the harm is lighter than that of the so-called strong drugs.
- Punishing a person for an act that can endanger only their own health is “aimless”.
- No inevitable link between marijuana and other crimes had been proved.
- The state may set criminal liability where the quantity makes distribution objectively inevitable, but 69 grams “cannot a priori be considered” an amount not meant for personal use.
Two sentences carry the argument. “A human shall not be an instrument of criminal policy and a tool for fight against crime.” And the state may not punish someone “only for deterring others from committing the same act”.
The ruling
| Point | Content |
|---|---|
| What was struck down | imprisonment as a punishment for buying and possessing, for personal use, dried marijuana in the disputed quantity, “up to 70 grams” |
| Constitutional basis | article 17(2) |
| Effect | in force from its announcement; final, with no appeal |
Judge Merab Turava dissented in part. He agreed that the penalty was disproportionate but thought the court should have struck down only severely disproportionate terms, not imprisonment of any length.
What it left alone
Buying and possessing marijuana stayed a crime; only prison was removed as the answer to it for amounts up to 70 grams. Use, growing and larger quantities were outside the case. The court dealt with those in later judgments, on use in 2017 and again in 2018.
Why the index moved
Possession rises from 1 to 2: holding up to 70 grams for oneself is still an offence, but it can no longer lead to prison. Enforcement rises from 1 to 2 for the same reason. Nothing else changes. The total moves from 9 to 14.[1]
Score by segment 0 to 10
- Possession · 25%1 → 2+1
- Personal cultivation · 25%1 → 1
- Punishment & enforcement · 20%1 → 2+1
- Sharing & gifting · 10%1 → 1
- Consumption · 10%1 → 1
- Legal access · 10%0 → 0
The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. Georgia's scores have changed again since.
References
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.