Cannabis Freedom Index
← History

Easing 🇬🇪 Georgia

Georgia's Constitutional Court ends criminal penalties for use

The court ruled that criminal punishment for consuming cannabis is unconstitutional, leaving only an administrative fine. Eight months later it struck down the fine as well.[3][1]

Index score

1419

+5 points

The story · written by opus-5.5,

Two years after it ruled out prison for possessing up to 70 grams, Georgia’s Constitutional Court turned to the act of using cannabis itself. Article 273 of the Criminal Code made consuming marijuana a crime when it was repeated. Givi Shanidze challenged it in complaint No. 732, and the First Chamber gave judgment on 30 November 2017.

A different right

The 2015 case had been argued as cruel punishment. This one was argued under article 16 of the Constitution, the right to the free development of one’s personality. The court held that choosing one’s recreation, including consuming marijuana, falls within the protected sphere of personal autonomy.

The state’s arguments, and the court’s answers

Argument for the banCourt’s finding
Public orderParliament offered no verified evidence that being under the influence raises the risk of crime
Gateway to other drugsno scientific evidence that marijuana creates a need for other narcotics
Distributionwith individual consumption “there is not even theoretical chance of distribution”
The user’s own healtha legitimate aim, but criminal liability to stop a person harming themselves is a “form of paternalism” that “is not compatible with the free society”

The court also objected to how broadly the article was drawn. It punished use “without any exceptions, regardless of place and situation of consumption”, with no regard to who the person was or what danger actually arose. It was declared incompatible with article 16.

The growing case, four months earlier

On 14 July 2017 the same chamber had ruled on three men who grew cannabis, with 63.73, 150.72 and 265.49 grams. It called imprisonment “purposeless and therefore, unjustified” for conduct that endangers only the person’s own health, and held prison disproportionate for the first two amounts. For 265.49 grams it accepted that the risk of distribution was high and that prison was a permissible kind of punishment, but found the term of six to twelve years out of proportion.

Why the index moved

Three scores rise by one point each. Consumption goes from 1 to 2: using cannabis is no longer a crime, though the administrative penalty for it stood for another eight months. Possession goes from 2 to 3 and enforcement from 2 to 3, reflecting that by the end of 2017 the court had removed prison for possession, criminal liability for use and prison for small-scale growing. Cultivation itself stays at 1, since growing remained an offence. The total moves from 14 to 19. The administrative penalty for use fell in July 2018.[1][2]

Score by segment 0 to 10

  1. Possession · 25%2 3+1
  2. Personal cultivation · 25%1 1
  3. Punishment & enforcement · 20%2 3+1
  4. Sharing & gifting · 10%1 1
  5. Consumption · 10%1 2+1
  6. Legal access · 10%0 0

The bar shows the score after the change; the tick marks where it stood before. Georgia's scores have changed again since.

References

  1. Constitutional Court of Georgia — Judgment N1/13/732, Givi Shanidze v. the Parliament of Georgia (30 November 2017)archived
  2. Constitutional Court of Georgia — Judgment N1/9/701,722,725, Gvianidze, Khomeriki and Gagishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia (14 July 2017)archived
  3. JAMnews — Marijuana use in Georgia, what does the law say?archived

Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read. The score before the change is an editorial estimate.

    ↑↓ to move, ↵ to open.