The story · written by opus-5.5,
One court in the United States has ever found a constitutional right to have cannabis at home.[1][2][3] It sits in Alaska, and its ruling of 1975 has outlived every attempt to undo it.[1]
A lawyer gets himself arrested
Irwin Ravin was an attorney. To challenge the law he arranged his own arrest in Anchorage, refusing to sign a traffic ticket while carrying marijuana. He said later that the fight had always been about privacy.[1]
The ruling
The Alaska Supreme Court decided Ravin v. State in May 1975, unanimously, in an opinion by Justice Rabinowitz.[1] It held that the privacy clause of the Alaska constitution, article I section 22, protects an adult’s use and possession of a small amount of marijuana in the home for personal use — the legislature’s own files describe the privacy right as prevailing over the state’s interest.[1][3]
The burden was on the state. It “must demonstrate a need based on proof that the public health or welfare will in fact suffer”, the court said, and “mere scientific doubts will not suffice”. Alaska lawmakers later called this the Ravin burden: without an adequate justification for intruding on the home, the ban could not stand.[1][3]
It is the first, and so far the only, decision by a state or federal court to recognise a constitutional privacy right covering cannabis.[1]
Voters and legislators push back
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1990 | Voters approve an initiative recriminalising possession |
| 2003 | In Noy v. State the Court of Appeals holds that an initiative is bound by the constitution like any law, and strikes the ban on less than four ounces at home |
| 2006 | The legislature makes more than one ounce a misdemeanour; a Juneau judge strikes it down |
| 2009 | The Supreme Court vacates that decision 3 to 2 because the plaintiffs lacked standing |
| 2014 | Voters legalise possession and sale, regulated like alcohol |
Why it is in the history
Ravin rests on a state constitution, so it bound no other state, and the index does not score states in its history. Rulings that protect private use were later given by the highest courts of South Africa, Georgia and Argentina.
Listed for context. No score change is recorded for United States here.
References
- Wikipedia — Ravin v. Statearchived
- Wikipedia — Legal history of cannabis in the United Statesarchived
- Alaska Legislature — Committee bill file SJUD16 SB 18 (1989–1990, 16th Legislature)Ravin v. State, 537 P.2d 494 (Alaska 1975): privacy Art. I sec. 22 prevailed; no adequate justification for the intrusion; the Ravin burden on the state.archived
Checked. The date and the event were compared with a source that was read.