docs/research/history-curacao-gap-2026-10-23.md +126 −0
@@ -0,0 +1,126 @@
+# Curaçao history gap and statutory exemptions — 23 October 2026
+
+This batch adds five entries to a three-entry timeline: the inherited ordinance's
+1964 commencement, the 2019 medicinal-industry advisory opinion and subsequent
+bill, opposition demands in 2023 and the 2024 review of exemption powers. It
+revises the 2018 prosecution-policy entry and the 2024 replacement-law entry,
+adds articles to the 2019 advice and 2024 law, and rewrites the existing 2018
+article. All six segment explanations and six context blocks now use inline
+citations. Numerical scores and all status classifications are preserved.
+
+## Primary sources and chronology
+
+Research downloads, extraction scripts and verification evidence are retained in
+`tmp/history-curacao-gap-2026-10-23/`. Exact source metadata is in `sources.json`.
+
+- Overheid.nl's original-ordinance metadata was downloaded and read. It records
+ signature on 28 March 1960 and commencement on **1 June 1964** under the
+ decree of 29 April 1964. The archived Antilles consolidation identifies the
+ replaced ordinance as that of 30 July 1929. Curaçao's own 2019 consolidation
+ identifies the inherited law and its acquisition of Curaçao-law status in 2010.
+ These sources establish continuity and commencement, not the original 1960
+ wording of every cannabis definition, penalty or medical exception.
+- The official Curaçao 2019 consolidated ordinance was downloaded in full
+ (`oldlaw2019.pdf/.txt`). Its relevant definitions, cultivation prohibition,
+ extracts/herbal-cannabis provisions, medical exceptions and penalties were read.
+ It is used as a later consolidation, without backdating those detailed rules
+ to 1964. It has no counterpart to the 2024 advertising article.
+- The original 2018/01 prosecution guideline was reread at pages 1–3 and 5–6
+ from the retained `tmp/pdfs/dutch-caribbean-2026-10-20/` download. It provides
+ confiscation and potentially conditional dismissal in the printed 0–25 g band;
+ the next printed 25–50 g band requests a fine up to NAf 500. The overlapping
+ endpoints are retained rather than silently resolving a boundary the table
+ does not resolve. From 50 g the cocaine/heroin requests are halved. Minors,
+ repeat offending, dealing indications, another offence and listed settings
+ are exceptions. The separate minor discussion covers even 0–5 g and assistance
+ services. General instructions include arrest/custody, resident first-offender
+ requests and differing treatment of non-residents. These are instructions,
+ not measured practice or mandatory judicial sentences.
+- The Advisory Council's complete 2019 substantive opinion was downloaded and
+ read (`advice2019.pdf/.txt`, printed pages 1–8). Its appendix was consulted for
+ context but editorial corrections there were not turned into events. Although
+ the PDF filename contains September, the signed opinion is dated **16 July
+ 2019**, visually verified on PDF page 8. The catalogue says publication on
+ 17 July. The opinion questions economic substantiation, licensing procedures,
+ financing of harvest purchases, repayment guarantees and the proposed bureau's
+ legal capacity. Its request for changes is not a veto or a refusal of a licence.
+- The full Curaçao Chronicle report of 18 September 2019 was downloaded and
+ read (`news2019.html/.txt`). It says the bill reached Parliament the preceding
+ week, so the bill event uses month precision, not the report date as an invented
+ exact filing day. It describes a proposed office, conditional on approval.
+- The full 8 October investor-interest report was read (`investors2019.html/.txt`).
+ Alvin Daal's nine applications/business plans and job/revenue projections do not
+ establish issued cultivation licences, actual jobs or realised revenue. It is
+ supporting context in the article, not a separate scored reform.
+- The full 7 April 2023 opposition report was downloaded and read
+ (`opposition2023.html/.txt`). It identifies MAN/KEM demands, Michelangelo
+ Martines, Giselle McWilliam and the earlier role of Suzanne Camelia-Römer.
+ It establishes that the bill was still awaiting approval then. It does not
+ certify its status throughout 2026. NU.CW's page returned a verification screen;
+ that search snippet was not substituted for a read source.
+- The 2024 Advisory Council opinion was downloaded as complete HTML
+ (`advice2024.html/.txt`); relevant general discussion, exemption procedure and
+ article 8a comments were read. The body dates signature to **15 May 2024**,
+ while the page labels publication as 6 June. The opinion describes pressure
+ from the planned financial-action evaluation and asks for explanation and
+ examples supporting the proposed broad exemption power. A guessed PDF address
+ returned 404 and is not presented as a recovered PDF.
+- The official 2024 law PDF, retained in the October 20 Dutch Caribbean research
+ directory, was reread at definitions, articles 2a–8a, 11 and 15–19. The final
+ text requires prior parliamentary approval for the government's intention to
+ create exemptions by decree, with a 30-day opportunity for Parliament to ask
+ that commencement be governed by legislation. This must not be replaced by
+ contemporary reporting about a draft suggesting no parliamentary role.
+ Articles 17–18 repeal the old ordinance and commence the new one the day after
+ publication: issued **5 July**, effective **6 July 2024**.
+
+## Profile corrections and scoring
+
+The former profile confused prosecutors' requests with actual sentences, treated
+medical professional exemptions too broadly and asserted no legal products or
+production without evidence of actual availability. The revised text states the
+specific rules instead. Article 3a handles extracts/tinctures, article 4 herbal
+cannabis/resin, and article 7 supplies specified exemptions. Professional handling
+of extracts and tinctures is subject to medicines rules; lawful personal treatment
+supplies require proof of need and lawful acquisition. An exemption is not proof
+of an operating pharmacy programme, patient registry or stock availability.
+
+The cultivation prohibition remains in article 2a. General exception-making power
+is not itself a personal plant allowance or a grant of a cultivation licence.
+The new advertising restriction excludes purely medical/scientific information;
+its breach has up to four months' detention or a fourth-category fine, or both.
+The 2024 event is now tightening, with an explicit unscored explanation: promotion
+of supply in an already prohibited recreational market changes no whole personal
+freedom band, while any future exemption requires a separate decree.
+
+The six current scores remain possession 4, cultivation 1, enforcement 4, sharing 1,
+consumption 2 and access 1. Medical remains `limited`. The score chain has no
+flagged transitions. The date when small-quantity leniency first began remains
+unresolved: 2018 replaced 2015 instructions, so it is not scored as the first
+introduction of leniency. Recovering earlier instructions and reconstructing the
+historical vector remains work for a future pass.
+
+The first-ban estimate remains in place. Searches found leads to the 1929 law,
+a 1935 international-control amendment and a 1956 penalty amendment, but did not
+recover enough original cannabis-specific coverage to replace the estimate or
+backdate a cannabis penalty. The later ordinance and 1929 replacement reference
+alone do not prove the first cannabis ban.
+
+## Validation and commit isolation
+
+The scoped verifier checks all seven touched entries, category and tag validity,
+titles, checked flags, related links, inline citation keys and use of listed
+sources. It checks source-identity deduplication across event and article text.
+Articles contain 358, 383 and 380 words, each with four headings and country and
+contextual history links. All twelve profile blocks have valid inline citations;
+current scores, dependency and status classifications match the starting snapshot.
+
+The production build passed: **3,872 pages in 34.20 seconds**. All **84 checked
+rendered citation links** resolved to unique numbered references; six tag pages,
+history exports and the profile API passed. The exact exported score remains
+**24.5**, medical Limited. `git diff --check` passed. Generated `site/` output
+was deleted after checking; source material and scripts remain. A separate Git index assembles the commit from only these seven
+history objects, the Curaçao profile, three articles and this note. Parent-to-commit
+semantic checks ensure unrelated history entries are unchanged. Concurrent edits,
+including Ohio history/profile changes and the source archive, remain outside
+this commit.